Does Justice Thomas Support Medical Marijuana?
Abolish the Bar Exam?

California Bar Exam Mishap

Shit, as they say, happens.  Especially to those studying for and taking the California Bar Exam.  Here's an excerpt from a letter sent to recent applicants:

It is with regret that I inform you that during the grading of the February 2005 California Bar Examination, several bar examination answer books  to Question number 6 were stolen from a grader's car....

Because a written scaled score cannot be calculated without a grade for each of the six essay questions, the Committee of the Bar Examiners determined that a score for Question 6 should be imputed for you and used to calculate your total score.

Or, as Kip noted, the State Bar "ma[de] scores up."  I hurt for those applicants.

A little context.  Question 1 on the California Bar tested Constitutional Law, specifically, the dormant Commerce Clause.  Question 6 tested Trusts. (I think!)  I would have loved to have my knowledge of con law imputed to my "knowledge" of trusts.  But the other way around and I would have been screwed.  As a commentor who suffered imputed scoring (during a different California Bar Exam) noted:

I was very strong in performance tests, strong in MBE, but pretty weak in essays. To make a long story short, I scored around 140 on the MBE, got a 140 on PT 1, but they used my weak essay scores to impute a score of 114 on PT 2, which had been cancelled due to the flooding.

Long story short, I scored 1424 [a 1440 is a passing score], and had I had the chance to take PT 2, which was easier than PT 1, I would have done well. Simply a 130 on PT 2 would have put me over the top, and I would have passed the exam.

Of course, the State Bar is unaccountable, so there's nothing to be done to help these victims: yes, someone who will be denied the right to practice law - and make money - for several months because of the State Bar's agents is a victim.  But, like I said, what can you do but take it?

(Hat tip: Amber Taylor, who is herself studying for the California Bar.)
 

Comments